• Question from:Justin Harford

When I am teaching evolution I often bring up the human testes to provoke some discussion - where is the testicular cage as with the ribs, cranium and pelvis?  Why not have them safely tucked up inside the body?  Ah they say they must be a couple of degrees below body temperature.   Ah yes I say but why evolve like that?  They are fairly vital kit in evolution after all. 

I then pose the question that is it a good idea that males have to reproduce and excrete out of the same tube?

I would be very grateful if you could shed some light on this ready for this lesson next time

Thanks

Justin

Justin Harford
Head of Biology
Bristol Grammar School

Photo
  • Horniman Museum, London, UK
  • Posts: 1,007

Great question for discussion. I will give my ideas backed up by some examples, but I am sure there will be other opinions!

1. Gross human morphology is strongly determined by ancestry, not just from other primates, but from basal placental mammals. Male mammals from seasonal regions tend to maintain their testes internally (or in a very reduced external form) until the breeding season, when the testes undergo rapid growth and they descend. This is a bit like human males going through puberty, except that it is reversible. This means that the testes are well protected without the need for energetically costly additional structures. As animals from a tropical environment we do not benefit from only having active reproductive organs during a brief breeding season (which means they don't need to be as large as animals that breed seasonally because we get more than one chance to deliver the sperm, meaning we need less at any given time). I assume that the selection pressures on having your testes outside the body are relatively low, so we simply haven't evolved a different arrangement.

2. Most vertebrates have a cloaca, which means that all of their waste and reproductive material shares a single exit duct. This is a very efficient mechanism since it requires less developmental input and takes up less space within the organism. The mechanism in humans for segregating reproductive and urinary functions in the penis is very effective. Also, urine is sterile as it exits the body, so it poses no problems, indeed it may help flush out the more infection prone reproductive material that doesn't exit the urethra during reproduction.

I'm sure there are plenty of other suggestions!

Paolo

Photo
  • QMUL, London
  • Posts: 1,078

More on testes sizes....

We also have small testes as we are in a relatively low sexually competitive environment. Compared to body size, the more or less monogamous gorilla (well, within the harem) has very small testes as the dominant male is more or less guaranteed to be the father of any offspring in the group.

In comparison the chimpanzee has colossal testes as females solicit mating from all males in the group when in season and thus there is a huge selection pressure on sperm competition, and by extension testicle size.

Humans lie somewhere in the middle! We are supposed to be monogamous, but that is more or less a socail pressure, not one determined by our evolution.